Christmas message to the Prime Minister of Australia

<sub>Thank you for your message to the Prime Minister at pm.gov.au.

Below is a copy for your records.
Responses prepared to your message will generally be emailed to you. If you have supplied a postal address, a response may be sent to you via Australia Post. In some cases, your message may be forwarded to other Federal Ministers for their consideration.

This is an automatically generated email. Please do not reply to this email as this address is not monitored.

If you have any problems with this service please contact the Web Administrator through the site feedback service at http://www.pm.gov.au/site-feedback

Submitted on Monday, 25 December, 2017 - 14:26


Title: Mr
First name: Mike
Family name: Griffin
Email address: mandm.griffin2@bigpond.com
Your address: 39, Rogers Drive, Valla Beach, NSW, 2448, Australia
Subject: Christmas message
Comment:
Dear Prime Minister Turnbull,
Yesterday, you stated, in your message to the nation: "please remember those who need our love and support now more than any other time". Well, I'm thinking about the detainees on Manus and Nauru, many of whom have been languishing in these hell-holes for more than four years. They have committed no crime. They have fled terror and persecution in their homelands to seek a place of safety in Australia, but it seems that there is no room in the inn. This utterly cruel and inhumane policy has done so much harm to these innocent people. Some have died, many have been ill-treated, and most of them have serious mental health issues resulting from their indefinite detention. If you are serious about the message of Christmas, then you should be telling the Australian people that enough is enough, and that these offshore detention centres will be permanently closed in 2018. End the torture. Bring them here!</sub>

Response to Tanya Plibersek letter 26 December 2017

_From: Mike

_{Sent: Tuesday, December 26, 2017 3:50 PM}

_{To: Tanya Plibersek MP}

_{Subject: Offshore detention}

_{Dear Ms Plibersek,}

_{Many thanks for your detailed response of 22nd December to my letter of 13th August, sent to Shayne Neumann and copied to you. I very much appreciate the time and trouble that you have taken to address the issues that I raised and to set out the Labor Party’s position. I do  accept, for the most part, the criticisms that you make of the Turnbull government’s utter failure to deal adequately with the appalling situation for asylum seekers and refugees languishing in offshore detention. But we need to address the problem of the elephant in the room. The Labor party went to the last election promising the Australian people that there was no difference between the Labor party and the Coalition in relation to the key pillars of asylum policy, namely: turning back the boats, the maintenance of offshore detention camps, and the Rudd-era policy of preventing people arriving by boat from ever settling in Australia. In these crucially important areas, the Labor party’s policy stance has not changed. It seems somewhat disingenuous to me for the Labor party to state that the detention camps were never regarded as being indefinite. Apart from the government’s incredibly stupid refusal to take up the NZ government’s offer to resettle 150 refugees annually, the Coalition tells the same story, and Dutton wants us to believe that he is trying to get people off Manus and Nauru as quickly as possible. In the meantime, many hundreds of asylum seekers and refugees continue to suffer both physically and mentally whilst politicians essentially look the other way.}

_{In the present terrible circumstances, the Labor party should bite the bullet, decide that enough is enough and take the political  risk of declaring that all detainees in offshore detention should be brought to Australia  without delay for their safety and well-being. This would allow an orderly progression to appropriate third countries, which would include the US and NZ, but would exclude Third World countries such as Cambodia. Those wishing to remain in Australia, where a number of them have family connections, should be allowed to do so.}

_{It is time to bring this shameful chapter in our history to an end.}

_{Yours sincerely,}

_{Mike Griffin}

_{39, Rogers Drive, Valla Beach NSW 2448}

reply from Tanya Plibersek Labor to letter sent 13 August 2017 - another death on Manus Island

_{From: Plibersek, Tanya (MP)}

_{Sent: Friday, December 22, 2017 12:37 PM}

_To: 'Mike'

_{Subject: RE: Another death on Manus Island}

_{Dear Mike}

_{I want to thank you for contacting me about refugee policy, and in particular the current situation on Manus Island. Let me also apologise for taking so long to get back to you. During this busy time I have been receiving a large volume of emails and while I am able to read them all and note the issues raised, I am not always able to respond as promptly as I would like.} 

_{I too am deeply concerned about the situation on Manus Island. It is completely unacceptable and the government has completely failed these refugees and asylum seekers. Under the Liberals, there have been delays, chaos, and secrecy. The generous offer from New Zealand has been on the table for three years now.  Mr Turnbull should accept it.} 

_{I have publicly stated my concern that the government should respond to the increasing tension following the closure of the Regional Processing Centre, and act urgently to ensure the safety and wellbeing of the refugees and asylum seekers on Manus. Instead of taking responsibility, Immigration Minister Peter Dutton is blaming refugees and their advocates. Malcolm Turnbull must step in to ensure refugees have immediate access to essential services – including security, health and welfare services - and safe resettlement.} 

_{The Turnbull government has been woefully incompetent in finding new permanent homes for refugees.} 

_{In government Labor had initiated a proper regional resettlement system which would have begun with asylum seekers living and working in Malaysia, with their children going to school and with proper health care, and Australia taking more refugees from the region. The Liberals prevented that from happening.}

_{The people on Manus and Nauru have been in limbo for far too long. Manus Island and Nauru were set up as temporary transit facilities, but have become places of indefinite detention because of the failure of the Turnbull government to negotiate third country resettlement options.} 

_{I'm also very concerned about the local community on Manus Island. Tensions are on the rise, including because of the lack of consultation prior to the proposed movement of refugees and asylum seekers. It is worrying that UNHCR representatives say that facilities for the men within the local community are still under construction, do not have water or electricity connected and have limited capacity. This puts great pressure on the local community.}

_{I have recently released a statement calling on Peter Dutton to answer very serious questions about new reports asylum seekers and refugees in Nauru have had medical treatment and transfers delayed by bureaucracy, including patients with breast lumps, kidney stones and neurological damage. These are serious allegations that cannot go unanswered.}

_{It was Labor that established a Senate Inquiry into serious allegations of abuse, self-harm and neglect of asylum seekers in relation to the Nauru Regional Processing Centre, and any like allegations in relation to the Manus Regional Processing Centre. The Senate Committee report is available at: http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Legal_and_Constitutional_Affairs/NauruandManusRPCs}

_{The government continues to refuse to accept recommendations from this inquiry.}

_{Labor is committed to policies that would provide better protection to those who are seeking asylum. I have attached more information about Labor’s policies below.}

_{Thank you again for getting in touch with me. I will continue to call on the Government to act to offer immediate protection and safe resettlement to refugees who have sought our protection.}

_{Yours sincerely}

_Tanya

_{Transcripts of my recent interviews and releases are available here} 



_{Attachment A}

_{In Government, Labor will:}

_{•           Support independent oversight of Australian-funded processing facilities;} 

_{•           Establish a children’s advocate to create a strong voice within government, independent of the Department of Immigration and Border Protection and backed by administrative resources and statutory powers to advocate for the interests of children seeking asylum and work to have children out of detention;}

_{•           Legislate to impose mandatory reporting of any child abuse in all facilities. There should be absolutely no doubt that staff, including medical contractors working in these facilities, not only have the freedom to report abuse, but have a legal obligation to do so; and}

_{•           Ensure that people working in the immigration system can safely speak out about abuse, maladministration and corruption.} 

_{Labor’s policy is to make sure that refugee claims are processed quickly and fairly. We would restore access to the Refugee Review Tribunal, and re-instate the ‘90-day rule’ for reporting on the progress of refugee claims.} 

_{Labor will also abolish Temporary Protection Visas which currently keep people in an unfair permanent state of limbo, and place those people found to be refugees on permanent protection visas.} 

_{Last election, Labor announced a commitment to do more to address the global humanitarian crisis.  This included increasing Australia’s humanitarian refugee intake to 27,000 per year by 2025 with a portion of the program dedicated to resettling refugees from the region.}

_{At a time when the global humanitarian need is greater than ever, Labor also committed to providing $450 million over three years to support the important work of the UNHCR.}

_{Labor will restore references to the UN Refugee Convention in the Migration Act and take a leadership role within South East Asia and the Pacific to build a regional humanitarian framework for asylum seekers. This will include supporting the UNHCR in providing health and education services to asylum seekers and advocating for work rights for asylum seekers.}

_{From: Mike [mailto:mandm.griffin2@bigpond.com]
Sent: Sunday, 13 August 2017 6:51 PM
To: Neumann, Shayne (MP)
Cc: Plibersek, Tanya (MP)
Subject: Another death on Manus Island}

_{Dear Mr Neumann,}

_{Earlier this month we learned of yet another death of an asylum seeker on Manus Island. Hamid Shamshiripoor was just 31 years old, and had spent more than three years on Manus Island as a result of the Labor government’s pronouncement four years ago that no asylum seekers arriving by boat would ever be resettled in Australia. It is not clear whether or not this poor young man, who was entitled to our protection, was murdered or committed suicide.  No matter, he is now dead.}

_{We do know that he had serious mental health problems.}

_{We do know that his fellow detainees pleaded in writing to the authorities in the detention centre  for Hamid to receive treatment for his illness.}

_{We do know that, instead of receiving treatment, Hamid was often imprisoned , bashed, moved around, and was finally homeless.}

_{We do know that his case was referred to the Australian Border Force’s chief medical officer some twelve months ago.}

_{We do know that he did not receive the care that he needed, and that he was entitled to.}

_{We do know that nobody in authority cares. And that includes your Party.}

_{And we do know that the Labor party, and you in particular, remains silent about these gross abuses of the human rights of refugees, for purely political purposes.}

_{When will the Labor party rediscover its heart, it’s soul and its principles? The party that I belonged to for more than 30 years cared about the vulnerable, the underprivileged, and about those in need. Not any more.} 

_{Mike Griffin}

₃

_p